【简答题】![](https://cos-cdn.shuashuati.com/shuashuati-web/2024-0521-0905-00/logo-new-ad743.png)
阅读下列材料。材料一 夏、商、周、汉封建(分封)而延,秦郡邑而促(短促)。材料二 秦有天下……不数载而天下大坏,其有由也:亟役万人,暴其刑威,竭其货贿。……咎在人怨,非郡邑之制失也。 ――柳宗元《封建论》 材料三 郡县之制,垂二千年而弗能改也,合古今上下皆安之,势之所趋,岂非理而能然哉?……郡县之法,已在秦先。秦之所灭六国者,非尽灭三代之所封也。 ――王夫之《读通鉴论》 回答:(1)关于秦朝灭亡的原因和郡县制的功过,材料一、材料二、材料三各是怎样评述的? _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ (2)你认为郡县制的推行与秦朝的灭亡有无关系?结合材料,应该怎样看待制度创新与王朝兴衰的关系? _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
![]()
手机使用
![](https://cos-cdn.shuashuati.com/shuashuati-web/2024-0521-0905-00/share-ico-3febd.png)
分享
![](https://cos-cdn.shuashuati.com/shuashuati-web/2024-0521-0905-00/link-f6c98.png)
复制链接
![](https://cos-cdn.shuashuati.com/shuashuati-web/2024-0521-0905-00/weibo-3e538.png)
新浪微博
![](https://cos-cdn.shuashuati.com/shuashuati-web/2024-0521-0905-00/qq-1c308.png)
分享QQ
![](https://cos-cdn.shuashuati.com/shuashuati-web/2024-0521-0905-00/wechat-a78ae.png)
微信扫一扫
微信内点击右上角“…”即可分享
![](https://cos-cdn.shuashuati.com/shuashuati-web/2024-0521-0905-00/report-ico-11843.png)
反馈
![收藏 - 刷刷题](https://cos-cdn.shuashuati.com/shuashuati-web/2024-0521-0905-00/coll-ico-cfcc9.png)
收藏
![](https://cos-cdn.shuashuati.com/shuashuati-web/2024-0521-0905-00/jubao-9c477.png)
举报
参考答案:
![](https://cos-cdn.shuashuati.com/shuashuati-web/2024-0521-0905-00/logo-new-ad743.png)
参考解析:
![](https://cos-cdn.shuashuati.com/shuashuati-web/2024-0521-0905-00/logo-new-ad743.png)